I have one of the original StrDry 4UP bags but only use it for trips where we would likely play in rain (Bandon). My everyday bags have been Players 4 and Players 4 Carbon with no issues. Coming from 55 years in the DFW area before settling into San Diego, I never thought StaDry was necessary and was concerned that the waterproof zippers would not last over time. Depending on if you walk a lot or need more storage, I would say Carbon, Players 4, or Players 4 Plus in the regular material. Everyone is a bit different but luckily Titleist has many options out there. Good luck with the next one and hit'm straight, stay safe.

I've recently gone to the Carbon Bag. High Marks and Highly Recommend .

Hey Todd. I just realized from your picture that you have the older round snap-on bag straps. Don't throw away that bag. If you list it for resale on eBay or a similar site, you should be able to sell it as a "parts bag". A few people have had those round connectors break and have been unable to get anything similar as a replacement to fix their straps. I am sure they would buy your old bag, just for the straps alone. You might even get some TT members that see this post want to reach out to you. That might help offset the cost of a replacement bag. Good luck.